All Products
View All
Air Tube Headsets
ElectraHealth Exclusives
Sales & Specials

EMF Meters
View All
Dirty Electricity Meters
Radiofrequency (RF) Wireless Meters
Electric Field (AC) Meters
Magnetic Field (AC) Meters
Body Voltage Meter Kits

Services
View All
Phone Consultations
On-Site Inspection - Analysis - Remediation

Filters
View All
STETZERiZER Original
DNA Filters

Shielding Products
Shielding Paint
Bed Canopies
Shielding Fabrics

Power Cables & Adapters
View All
Power Strips
Extension Cords
Device Cords

Networking
View All
Wired and WiFi Routers
Ethernet LAN Cables
Grounding Adapters
Cat 6
Cat 7

Books and Videos

Professional
View All
Pro Meters
Pro Meter Accessories
Pro Miscellaneous
ElectraHealth EMF Newsletter with The EMF Explorer's Exclusive Content, Promotions, Specials Signup

RISK-FREE
Your Stetzerizer Filter purchase is covered by a 60 day no questions 100% satisfaction guarantee!!!
60 - Day 100% Satisfaction Guarantee on all Stetzerizer products!!!

Stetzerizer Filters do not wear out or ever need replacement. They are a one-time investment for a lifetime of healthier living.

Shopper Award



Would you prefer to make easy monthly payments on your order? We accept PayPal's Bill Me Later, allowing you 6 months interest free financing. Just place your order as normal, choose PayPal as the payment method, and follow the Bill Me Later link.

Naperville IL Fails to Consider Privacy Interests of Residents during Smart Grid Implementation

Posted by Bob on 10/15/2013 to "Smart" Meters
Original Source

NAPERVILLE, IL — The widespread deployment of smart meters has resulted in serious concerns that such devices unreasonably invade the privacy of consumers.  Some of the main privacy concerns that have been reported in the literature are summarized below.

Privacy Concerns Related to Smart Meter

As a general rule, the ability to discern occupancy and specific activities from smart meters depends on the time resolution of the energy consumption data collected.  Daily readings would generally enable one to determine dwelling occupancy over time.  As the data collection intervals are further reduced, a load profile is revealed that allows determination of general movement and activities within a dwelling on an hour by hour basis.  With further increased granularity of the data, usage of individual appliances within a dwelling can be identified.  For example, as indicated on page 14 of NIST Document NISTIR 7628, “Guidelines for Smart Grid Cyber Security: Vol. 2, Privacy and the Smart Grid,” research shows that analyzing 15-minute interval household energy consumption data can by itself pinpoint the use of most major home appliances.

Since smart meters represent a threat to the personal privacy of consumers, it is essential that the amount of data collected by smart meters be limited to the bare minimum necessary to accomplish utility objectives.

As outlined on page 20 of NIST Document NISTIR 7628, Vol.2 (full title mentioned above):

“In the current operation of the electric utilities, data taken from traditional meters consists of basic data usage readings required to create bills.  Under the Smart Grid implementation, smart meters will be able to collect other types of data. … Some of this additional data may constitute personal information or may be used to determine personal activities.  Because of the associated privacy risks, only the minimum amount of data necessary for services, provisioning, and billing should be collected.” [emphasis added]

Additionally, in December 2012, a document was published entitled, “A Model Privacy Policy for Smart Grid Data.”  This document was prepared by the Vermont Law School and supported by a Department of Energy Award # DE-OE0000446.  On page 3, it states that:

 “Before collecting any new confidential information from Customers or implementing any programs or systems that automatically collect Confidential Information, the Utility shall determine what Confidential Information is reasonably necessary [emphasis added] to effectively implement Smart Grid Technology.”
Balancing ActBased upon the above information it is evident that a utility’s goal to enhance its electrical grid operations must be balanced with the privacy interests of the consumer.  This “balancing” would require that a privacy impact assessment be performed where a utility would consciously, thoughtfully, and methodically ensure that the data collection capabilities of a smart meter did not unreasonably infringe on the privacy expectations of the consumer.  Was such a privacy impact assessment performed for the City of Naperville’s implementation of its smart grid initiative?  Evidently not based upon the paragraphs that follow.

As documented in the Federal lawsuit of Naperville Smart Meter Awareness vs. City of Naperville, Document # 51-2 of Case # 11-CV-09299, please review the following verbal exchange regarding smart meter data collection frequencies:

COURT:  “Is there a reason why the 15-minute unit time was chosen as opposed to daily or — … weekly?”

CITY:  “Yes. … we chose the 15-minute interval because of our overall program and our — our need to be able to determine our energy usage on a more accurate basis for purposes of buying our power out in the marketplace.  And so that when we buy our power, we buy it more accurately.”

COURT:  “Okay.  With regard to — let’s put it this way:  Is there magic as to 15 minutes as opposed to an hour, as opposed to 30 minutes, as opposed to five minutes?”

CITY:  “Your Honor, we chose 15 minutes as – it was a balance between the meters’ memory capacity, cost of the meters, and the resolution that we would have liked to obtain information where we could lower demand and provide cost savings.” [emphasis added]

COURT:  “In other words, you could have bought meters that sent off information every five minutes, but they would have been more expensive?”

CITY:  “That’s correct, your Honor.  More expensive, or we could retain less than the amount of information that we needed inside the meter.”

As you can see from the Court proceedings, there is no indication that the privacy interests of the individual were even remotely considered in determining the data collection capabilities of the smart meter.  In fact, if it were not for cost considerations, there is an implication that the City may have purchased meters configured to collect electrical usage data even more frequently than the current 15-minute interval … resulting in even greater privacy invasions for consumers.

So rather than balancing the privacy interests of consumers with the City’s goal to enhance its electrical grid operations, the City formally stated in a Court of law that the current 15-minute smart meter data collection interval was determined by balancing such factors as memory capacity and cost.  There was no mention of customer privacy as a consideration.  As such, the City has failed to follow the basic common sense guidelines given at the beginning of this article in deciding what private and/or confidential data may reasonably be collected from the customer without consent.

Since the City of Naperville and its municipally owned utility have failed to properly consider the privacy interests of its customers, there exists yet another compelling reason why the City should promptly provide analog electrical usage meters to all customers requesting them at no additional cost to the consumer.
comments powered by Disqus

 The EMF Explorer
 Dirty Electricity
 "Smart" Meters
 Wireless

 Mobile phones are 'cooking' men's sperm
 Tips on How to Save Energy and Money without a ‘Smart’ Meter
 Families Punished by ‘Smart’ Meters and Time-Of-Use Rates, Recent Study Confirms
 TEDx Talk: “Wireless Wake-Up Call”
 A Message to Dads about Wireless Safety
 EMF Controversy Exposed
 Li-Fi has just been tested in the real world, and it's 100 times faster than Wi-Fi
 Electromagnetic Radiation Soup
 Effects of GSM EMR on permeability of blood-brain barrier in rats
 Psychiatric symptoms associated with exposure to non-ionizing EMR from mobile telephones
 Italian town shuts down school Wi-Fi over health fears
 Electromagnetic Radiation : ‘Wake-Up Call’ For Everyone
 Smart meters: boon or boondoggle?
 Summary of Evidence on Smart Meter Fires
 The REAL tin foil hat: RF protection for your head
 Study: EMF Radiation generated by mobile phone base stations associated with type 2 diabetes
 Protect yourself from health dangers of exposure to wireless networks
 Wait, so cell phones cause brain cancer after all?
 Study: Impairments in spinal cord of male offspring rats following exposure to a continuous 900-MHz EMF
 'Smart Meters:' Easy Targets for Hackers
 New Itron OpenWay Riva ‘Smart’ Meters Combine RF Mesh, PLC and Wi-Fi Communications and Poll Data Once per Second
 ‘Catastrophic’ Failures Expected with ‘Smart’ Meters
 Congressional Testimony: ‘Smart’ meters only have a life of 5 to 7 years
 T-Mobile wants to turn your house into a cell tower, and why you should think twice about letting them
 US pushes for spectrum for 5G, civil drones, flight tracking
 Study shows radioprotective effects of a natural leaf extract
 Practical Tips to Reduce Electromagnetic Radiation Exposure
 An Inside View of a "Smart" Meter
 Should babies and toddlers use mobile devices every day?
 4G/LTE in Unlicensed Bands - Adding Electromagnetic Radiation to an Airspace Near You

 March 2016
 February 2016
 January 2016
 December 2015
 November 2015
 October 2015
 September 2015
 August 2015
 July 2015
 June 2015
 May 2015
 April 2015
 March 2015
 February 2015
 January 2015
 December 2014
 November 2014
 October 2014
 September 2014
 August 2014
 July 2014
 June 2014
 May 2014
 April 2014
 March 2014
 February 2014
 January 2014
 December 2013
 November 2013
 October 2013
 September 2013
 August 2013
 July 2013
 June 2013
 May 2013
 April 2011